Answer in two sentences: Match what you want to feel in your mouth and what you want to share. If you want rich, chewy bites and bold mix ins choose our super premium, chunky, swirly flavors; if you want something playful to share pick a sundae or a thick milkshake, and if you want a cozy, smaller treat consider a hot chocolate pairing.
How we think about cravings
We build our menu around three simple qualities that steer every good choice: texture, flavor intensity and occasion. Texture is the mouthfeel you crave, from dense and scoopable to silky and drinkable. Flavor intensity ranges from subtle vanilla notes to bold, spiced or boozy compositions that stand up to mix ins. Occasion covers whether you want a solo treat after a hike in Draper, a family share at a birthday, or a playful date night with colonial themed theatrics.
When you pick a scoop here you are choosing more than taste, you are choosing an experience. Our colonial themed decor and costumed team add a theatrical touch, and seasonal or limited run flavors keep options fresh for repeat visits.
Match texture to your craving
Dense and indulgent
Our super premium base is dense and rich, with a high butterfat content and large chunks or ribbons folded in. Choose these flavors when you want a slow melting, spoonable scoop that shows off chunky inclusions like cookie pieces or swirls of caramel.
Silky and smooth
If you want something that glides, choose a flavor with a smoother churn and fewer big mix ins. These scoops pair well with delicate sauces and lighter toppings, and they work nicely if you plan to add a hot beverage alongside.
Drinkable and thick
Milkshakes and hand stirred thick shakes are a different category. If your craving is for a spoonable drink or a sharable straw experience, our milkshakes deliver thick, velvety texture that bridges dessert and beverage. See our notes on milkshake texture for what to expect.
Match flavor profile to mood
Think of flavor as a tone: comforting, bright, spicy, or adventurous. Here are quick rules of thumb we use behind the counter.
- Comforting: Classic vanilla based recipes and simple mix ins, excellent for kids and those who prefer familiar tastes.
- Bright and refreshing: Citrus or fruit forward scoops, good after outdoor activities or with lighter desserts.
- Spicy or complex: Flavors with ginger, toasted nuts, or boozy notes that reward slow tasting and discussion.
- Playful and theatrical: Limited edition or themed flavors that pair with our staff theatrics and seasonal specials.
We name many of our flavors after Founding Fathers and moments in early American history, which makes choosing a scoop a chance to try something inventive while enjoying a playful theme.
Choose by occasion
Family outings and birthday groups
For families, we favor shareable formats. Large sundaes and build your own options let everyone sample without committing to one scoop. Our sundaes menu offers combinations designed to balance textures and avoid flavor clash. Learn more about our sundaes if you are planning a group treat.
Casual dates and couples
Couples often enjoy two small scoops with complementary sauces, or a thick milkshake to share. The theatrical setting in our shop creates a relaxed atmosphere where dessert becomes the focus of conversation.
Solo indulgence or a quick stop
A single scoop of a bold, super premium flavor is a satisfying treat after a hike in Draper or a shopping trip. If you want a warmer finish, try one of our desserts or a cup of drinking chocolate alongside your scoop.
How we help you decide in store
- Tell us the texture you want. We will steer you toward a dense scoop, a silky option, or a shake.
- Pick a flavor family. Start with chocolate, nuts, fruit, or something seasonal. We will point out limited time flavors by their intensity.
- Consider sharing or pairing. Decide if you want a sundae to share, a milkshake for two, or a single scoop with a hot chocolate on the side.
Pro tip: If you cannot decide, ask for a small taste before you commit. We offer samplers of rotating flavors so you can compare textures and mix ins without ordering full scoops.
Practical checklist for group orders and parties
Before you arrive
- Decide how many people will share and whether you want sundaes or individual scoops.
- Note any known allergies or dietary restrictions so we can suggest safe options.
- Check seasonal flavors to pick limited runs that excite the group.
At the counter
- Ask about texture if you care more about mouthfeel than flavor name.
- Consider one bold scoop paired with a milder one for variety when sharing.
- Choose vessels that make sharing easy, like large sundae dishes or split shakes.
Dietary notes and allergens
We use a super premium dairy base for many of our flavors and we fold in large mix ins on site. Because of that process, cross contact is possible. Let us know about allergies when you order and we will suggest safer choices from our current menu. We also offer options that are lighter on dairy and seasonal choices that accommodate different preferences. For details about ingredients and care we follow manufacturer guidance for storage and handling.
Watch out: If someone in your group has a severe allergy, avoid shared spoons and shared serving dishes. Tell our team so we can take extra precautions.
Sundaes, milkshakes and when to choose each
Pros
- Sundaes make sampling multiple flavors easy.
- Milkshakes are great for on the move and for a drinkable dessert experience.
- Both showcase our theatrical presentation and seasonal toppings.
Cons
- Sundaes can be messy with many toppings if you need a neat option.
- Milkshakes hide texture details that are more obvious in scoop form.
For guidance on presentation and vessels see our topic on cone and vessel selection. If you plan an event, our party and event treats notes explain what works best for groups.
What good looks like when you choose well
A well chosen ice cream order satisfies the craving quickly and leaves everyone glad they came. Look for these quality markers when you order:
- Dense, scoopable texture with visible mix ins for chunky flavors.
- Clean, balanced flavors where toppings enhance rather than overpower the base.
- Seasonal or limited flavors that taste fresh and have clear identity.
Key takeaway
Pick by texture first, then by flavor intensity and occasion. That sequence helps you choose a scoop that matches your craving and makes the visit memorable.
Related reading and places to learn more
For a deeper look at tasting and texture we recommend our sensory tasting guide. To see our full ice cream offerings visit our ice cream page. If you are visiting from nearby communities, get local highlights for our neighborhood on the Draper, Utah location page.
Frequently asked questions
How do I decide between a single scoop and a sundae?
Choose a single scoop when you want to focus on one strong flavor or a quick treat. Choose a sundae when you want to share, try multiple textures, or enjoy decorative sauces and toppings.
Can I sample flavors before I buy?
Yes. We encourage small tastes of rotating flavors so you can compare texture and intensity before ordering a full scoop.
What are your most family friendly choices?
Families often choose our classic flavors and combo sundaes because they offer variety and sharing options. Our menu is designed to appeal to kids and adults alike.
Do you have non dairy options?
We offer seasonal choices and lighter dairy options from time to time. Ask at the counter for current non dairy selections and ingredient details.
Are your flavors available for parties and events?
We supply a range of party friendly formats and recommend planning ahead for large groups. See our event notes under party and event treats for guidance.
What should I tell staff if someone has an allergy?
Tell us the specific allergy when you order. Because we mix and fold large inclusions on site, we can suggest safer choices and take extra care to minimize cross contact.
Want to see our current flavors and reviews?
Check our Google Business Profile to read recent reviews and get directions, and explore related pages on our site to plan your visit.